9 Comments
User's avatar
Politics and Sausage Making's avatar

The reality is that innovation cannot stop, especially one-sided innovation that constrains Americans and not the Chinese. But trying to stop AI's advancement would be like Roosevelt trying to stop nuclear research in the hope that our enemies wouldn't have suddenly developed a weapon themselves. The key will be how we regulate a capable AI that could, if not contained, be highly destructive. Like the US and the USSR, the most dangerous powers will have to come together to voluntarily restrain their own destructive capabilities, knowing that mutually assured destruction applies as much to AI as it did to nuclear weapons. It won't be altruistic. It will be out of necessity and the will to live. Then we have to stop and think about whether there are certain countries we don't want to have the capacity for the most capable AI systems. AI non-proliferation might be a major issue in the future. And it might be a lot harder than nuclear non-proliferation.

Michael Kole's avatar

If it can be built, it will be built. You can’t ‘pause’ or stop innovation. Somebody will build it, and it will be a tool that can be used for good or evil. We pray good wins.

Richard's avatar

True, but it can be regulated, just like nuclear arms were.

Michael Kole's avatar

Governments can try, but it’s not like building nuclear weapons. You don’t need enriched uranium … you need a computer, and that computer can be in a basement in Iran or Russia.

jbnn's avatar

Why The Buildout Can’t Stop

So let’s bring it back to the two tests from the beginning. A bubble is money poured into something the world doesn’t need yet, by people who can stop when the belief fades. What’s being built now is the only exit from a fifty-year debt trap, it’s sold before it’s built, and the people paying for it can’t pause without losing to each other or to the country across the Pacific. Neither test comes close.

That doesn’t mean it’ll be smooth. There’ll be scares. A lab will fail. A quarter will wobble. And each time a little voice will tell you this is the top.

Ignore it. Zoom out, look at the queues for transformers and grid connections that are still years long, and remember that the thing driving this was never sentiment. The companies and countries building it can’t stop, and the returns go to whoever owns the compute, the energy that feeds it, and the rails it runs on. So own the rails, and stop trying to trade the wobbles.

https://raoulpal.substack.com/p/why-the-buildout-cant-stop?utm_source=post-email-title&publication_id=1060800&post_id=215093968&utm_campaign=email-post-title&isFreemail=true&r=6mos7&triedRedirect=true&utm_medium=email

SandyG's avatar

THEY (companies and countries) can't run it without data centers, and The People, who own the land and the electricity, are having a say in whether they get built. Of course, in China, the government owns the land and the electricity. So there's that argument for destroying liberal democracy. 🤔

Richard's avatar

Data centers don't have to reside in the US, even if the People of the US somehow manage to ban data centers. And as you noted yourself, China won't stop. So is a world where the US deliberately decides to be weaker than the PRC a better and safer one?

SandyG's avatar

There’s another alternative, as the nations did with nuclear arms agreements.