Six-Chart Sunday EXTRA – Off-Year Elections
One Day Later
A rare weekday edition with six takes on this week’s contests.
1. Democrats Won Everywhere
It was a big night for the Democratic Party all across the country.
2. Major Win for Dems in Redistricting Wars
Newsom (and Pelosi) succeed in offsetting earlier GOP House gains in Texas. Net-net, the redistricting wars seem likely to deliver 2-6 seats for the GOP. Newsom rides on towards 2028, Pelosi off into the sunset?
3. Simplest Explanations Usually Best
NYC was NYC, NJ was NJ, and VA did what it always does — the opposite of the prior year’s Presidential result. Over the past half-century, the party not in the White House won the Virginia Governorship 12/13 times.
4. Economic Issues Dominated
“Economic worries were the dominant concern as voters cast ballots for Tuesday’s elections, according to preliminary findings from the AP Voter Poll. The results of the expansive survey of more than 17,000 voters in New Jersey, Virginia, California and New York City suggested the public was troubled by an economy that seems trapped by higher prices and fewer job opportunities.”
5. Activism Rises vs Party in Power
Out-party voters are energized, active and loud. In-power voters are often frustrated that their teams’ promises prove harder to accomplish, take too long or require compromises they don’t like.
6. Expect More Retirements
Per Axios: “If the redistricting brush fire continues to blaze across the country, wiping out as many as a dozen incumbents from each party, the number [of House retirements] is likely to soar…. [with] Proposition 50 passe[d], four GOP incumbents are suddenly facing long odds. Retirement might look more dignified than a long-shot reelection bid… Factor in the growing youth rebellion in the Democratic Party [likely energized by Mamdani’s win in NYC] and it’s pretty clear the House of Representatives will look considerably different when the next Congress is sworn in… November and January typically see the most retirement announcements of the cycle.”










Your charts tell the story of the election. One other topic that might be worth exploring is the enormity of the gender gap. In Virginia, Spanberger won women by 30%, while Sears carried men by 8%. The gap itself is not a story - the size of this one is. With two women facing each other in Virginia, the gender of the candidate is not a satisfactory explanation.
Great chart on Virginia elections - correction needed: Robb was elected Governor in 1981.